SPRINGFIELD, IL – Hospital Sisters Health System today announced that Andrew J. Bagnall, MHA, FACHE, has been appointed to serve as President and Chief Executive Officer for HSHS Sacred Heart Hospital and HSHS Western Wisconsin Division. Mr. Bagnall currently serves as President and CEO of HSHS St. Nicholas Hospital in Sheboygan, Wisconsin. He will begin this new role on February 5.

Since joining HSHS in 2010, Mr. Bagnall has helped transform the culture at St. Nicholas by leading initiatives that improved quality, safety, the patient experience and colleague and physician engagement. Furthermore, he has advanced the integration and alignment of Prevea Health and other physician groups. Mr. Bagnall also oversaw the financial turnaround of the hospital, the growth of patient services, and major capital projects including the renovation of the hospital’s surgical platform and the ICU.

“With Andy’s many accomplishments at St. Nicholas over the last eight years, he was a clear choice for this leadership role for the HSHS Western Wisconsin Division,” HSHS President and CEO Mary Starmann-Harrison said. “We know Andy will bring proven leadership and results-driven processes to the Chippewa Valley as our team continues to enhance and grow our patient-first care.”

Chairman of the HSHS Sacred Heart Hospital and HSHS St. Joseph’s Hospital Board of Directors, David Kiefer, echoed Starmann-Harrison’s remarks.

“Andy is a proven leader and his experience, energy and enthusiasm will help advance our mission and take our health care system to the next level,” Kiefer said. “Our board members are impressed with all that he has accomplished during his career, especially during the past eight years working for HSHS in Sheboygan. He’s going to be a great addition to our team and we look forward to working with him.”

“It has truly been an honor and privilege to serve our patients and the residents of Sheboygan and be part of such an exceptional team in Eastern Wisconsin. I’m humbled that HSHS leadership and western Wisconsin board members have asked me to take on this new leadership role for HSHS,” Mr. Bagnall said. “I look forward to joining our colleagues in western Wisconsin to build on the great work they’re doing to provide high quality patient-centered care that not only improves the lives of individuals but also improves the health and quality of life for the communities of Eau Claire and Chippewa Falls,” he added.

Prior to joining HSHS, Mr. Bagnall served as Chief Executive Officer at Select Specialty Hospital in Davenport, Iowa and as Vice President for Grinnell Regional Medical Center in Grinnell, Iowa. He earned a Master’s Degree in Health Administration and Bachelor of Arts Degree from St. Ambrose University in Davenport, Iowa, and is a Fellow of the American College of Healthcare Executives. In 2011, he was named as one of Modern Healthcare’s “Up and Comers.” Mr. Bagnall has been very active in the Sheboygan community, serving on numerous local boards, including the Lakeshore Technical College Foundation, Sheboygan County Chamber of Commerce, and Sheboygan County Economic Development Board.

Mr. Bagnall, his wife and three children plan to relocate to the Chippewa Valley.

With Mr. Bagnall’s transition to Western Wisconsin, Therese Pandl, President and CEO, HSHS Eastern Wisconsin, will serve as the interim President and CEO for HSHS St. Nicholas Hospital until a new President and CEO is appointed.
About Hospital Sisters Health System
Hospital Sisters Health System’s (HSHS) mission is to reveal and embody Christ’s healing love for all people through our high quality, Franciscan health care ministry. HSHS provides state-of-the-art health care to our patients and is dedicated to serving all people, especially the most vulnerable, at each of our 15 Local Systems and physician practices in Illinois (Breese, Decatur, Effingham, Greenville, Highland, Litchfield, O’Fallon, Shelbyville and Springfield) and Wisconsin (Chippewa Falls, Eau Claire, Oconto Falls, Sheboygan, and two in Green Bay). HSHS is sponsored by Hospital Sisters Ministries. For more information about HSHS, visit www.hshs.org. For more information about Hospital Sisters of St. Francis, visit www.hospitalsisters.org.

Media Contacts

Dana Jermstad

Director of Communications and Public Relations
 (920) 429-1752


Angela Deja

Public Relations Manager
(920) 272-3360

Latest News

HSHS St. Nicholas Hospital presents: A Visit with St. Nicholas

 November 15, 2022

HSHS St. Nicholas Hospital warmly invites community members to attend A Visit with St. Nicholas, an event embracing the traditional spirit of Christmas and celebrating the hospital’s patron...


HSHS St. Nicholas Hospital presents 25th Annual St. Nicholas Eve Gala

 November 3, 2022

Tickets are available for the 25th Annual St. Nicholas Eve Gala, hosted by the HSHS St. Nicholas Foundation, Friday, Dec. 2, at The Osthoff in Elkhart Lake.


Health and safety reminders ahead of November’s nine-day deer hunt

 October 28, 2022

As hunters take to the woods, marshes and fields across Wisconsin for the traditional nine-day deer hunt in November, HSHS St. Nicholas Hospital asks all to keep health and safety top of mind.